by: Dylan Allman

Nine days after the towers fell, George W. Bush stood before Congress and told a grieving country why it had been attacked. They hate our freedoms, he said, our freedom of religion, our freedom of speech, our freedom to vote and assemble and disagree with each other. Americans believed him. If he was right, and the men who flew those planes wanted our freedom gone, the only question left is who handed it to them.

In a tape released days before the 2004 election, Osama bin Laden mocked the freedom story and asked why, if liberty were the target, he had never struck Sweden. His plan was to bleed America to the point of bankruptcy, he said, and he boasted that the attacks had cost al-Qaeda about half a million dollars and cost the United States more than five hundred billion.

Nineteen men with box cutters killed nearly three thousand people in a single morning. Everything after that morning required a vote. Bush signed the USA PATRIOT Act forty-five days later, a bill hundreds of pages long, written and passed in a matter of weeks, and it cleared the Senate ninety-eight to one. Congress built the Department of Homeland Security, the largest reorganization of the federal government since the Pentagon was created in 1947, and directed the Transportation Security Administration to search every traveler in the land. In 2008 it added Section 702 to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, which lets agents sweep up Americans’ messages without a warrant.

In March 2013 Senator Ron Wyden asked James Clapper, the Director of National Intelligence, whether the NSA collected any type of data at all on millions of Americans. Clapper told him no. Three months later, whistleblower Edward Snowden handed over a secret court order requiring Verizon to surrender the records of its customers’ calls every day under Section 215 of the Patriot Act. He revealed that, through a program called PRISM, the NSA pulled email, chats and stored files from Google, Facebook, Apple, Microsoft and Yahoo. Its analysts used XKeyscore to search through nearly everything a person did online, from email to browsing history, and the agency tapped the private cables running between Google’s and Yahoo’s own data centers. Snowden was quickly charged under the Espionage Act and has lived in exile in Russia ever since. CNN later hired Clapper as a national security analyst.

Shoes off through airport security. Belt off. Arms up inside the scanner. Liquids in a quart bag. Grandmothers patted down and toddlers swabbed. When the Department of Homeland Security’s own investigators tested the checkpoints in 2015, they successfully carried weapons and mock explosives through ninety-five percent of the time.

The wars that followed cost about eight trillion dollars. Washington put nearly all of it on credit, and the interest on that borrowing alone has passed a trillion dollars. When the next crisis came, the Federal Reserve swelled its balance sheet from four trillion dollars to nine in two years, conjuring money to buy the government’s own paper. In fiscal 2026 the Treasury paid more than a trillion dollars in net interest, a record share of the economy, and the year before, interest outran all spending on defense. The debt is paid with new debt, the new debt is bought with new money, and the new money is taken from you at every register.

A people that once hanged its tyrants in effigy learned to ask permission. National security became the justification that ends every argument, and the state found it could have anything it asked for. License plate readers log where your car parks every night. Age verification laws demand your government ID before you may open a website the state disapproves of. Central bankers sketch a digital dollar that could be programmed, frozen or expired with a keystroke. After every massacre the same bill comes back to disarm people who harmed no one. Each of them walks through a door that was kicked open in the autumn of 2001.

Bin Laden spent a decade running and died in a compound in Abbottabad in 2011. The men who voted for the Patriot Act went home to reelection, and much of what they wrote is still the law. He robbed a nation with box cutters and was hunted to the end of the earth for it. They robbed it under cover of law, by roll call, with the cameras rolling, and were thanked for keeping us safe. Al-Qaeda wanted Americans poorer and more afraid, and it had neither the army nor the money printer to make it so. Washington had both.

In May 2003 a banner hung over the deck of an aircraft carrier and told the world the mission was accomplished. It was. The banner hung over the wrong building. It belongs on the Capitol.

Dylan Allman is a libertarian writer and philosopher. He is the creator of hostis.black. You can find his work on dylanallman.info, and on X at @dylanallman.