by: Andy Evans – Straits Area LP

In the year 1787, on a chilly and overcast September day in Philadelphia, a greatly aged Benjamin Franklin struggled down the steps of the Pennsylvania State House – for one final time. The Constitutional Convention delegates had just finished their work with 38 signatures. As the old man exited, he was approached by Ms. Elizabeth Powel. She inquired, “Mr. Franklin, do we have a Monarchy or a Republic?” His reply: “We have a Republic – if you can keep It.”

Earlier that day, Franklin had made the motion to approve the final version of our Constitution. While speaking in support, he made another pessimistic assessment whether our great experiment would succeed:

“In these sentiments, Sir, I agree to this Constitution, with all its faults, if they are such; because I think a General Government necessary for us, and there is no form of government, but what may be a blessing to the people if well administered; and believe further, that this is likely to be well administered for a course of years, and can only end in despotism, as other forms have done before it, when the people shall become so corrupted as to need despotic government.” 

As we near the 240th anniversary of that day, most would agree that the Federal Government of 2026 hardly resembles what our Founders had envisioned. With a payroll of over four million people, a military budget of one trillion dollars, and over four hundred agencies, this massive institution now holds sway over much of our daily lives. A nation once driven by industry and farming now seems to be powered by bureaucrats and fueled by the taxpayer. As for the officials entrusted to protect our Constitution, oversee our government, create our laws, and “faithfully execute” said laws – the process of electing them has also become a major industry. This year alone, nearly twelve billion dollars was spent on Congressional campaigns – an amount tripled from ten years prior.

Past attempts to regulate such spending have spawned dozens of Supreme Court cases dealing with the many complexities of supporting political candidates. Some notable rulings include Buckley v. Valeo, Austin v. Michigan Chamber, McConnell v. FEC, FEC v. National Conservative PAC, and Citizens United v. FEC. In all such cases, the justices have struggled to balance free speech and associative rights against the need to, in the words of Justice Byron White, “avoid real or apparent corruption …”

This author concedes that in our modern mass-media driven society, expression of political thought has significant costs – making the Almighty Dollar a unit of political speech. Our mailboxes, airwaves, and browsers now bombard us with unlimited advertisements. There should be no shame in having wealth, but having the means to fund massive messaging platforms raises concerns regarding the corruption of legislators – and even Presidents. In a cautionary SCOTUS dissent, Justice White wrote:

“The act of giving money to political candidates, however, may have illegal or other undesirable consequences: it may be used to secure the express or tacit understanding that the giver will enjoy political favor if the candidate is elected. Both Congress and this Court’s cases have recognized this as a mortal danger against which effective preventive and curative steps must be taken.”

A significant slice of political contributions is now delivered by means of “Dark Money” through Super PACs and various non-profits. And oh, how that pie has grown. According to data from OpenSecrets.org, Super PAC-driven outside spending on campaigns grew elevenfold – from 395 million dollars to nearly 4.5 billion – in the fourteen years following the Citizens United court decision. In our most recent election cycle of 2026, Elon Musk contributed 445 million while nine others gave at least 50 million. Two cryptocurrency corporations also spent over 50 million. If money actually talks, it is apparent that billionaires and corporations now dominate the conversation.

There are certainly libertarian arguments for allowing such spending during elections, as an expression of our First Amendment free speech rights. Libertarians would also question any limits on the freedom of association to pool individual resources, such as the use of union dues in support of candidates or parties. To overcome the power of candidate incumbency, significant spending can certainly make the difference – as Thomas Massie found out this summer after being the target of over 15 million dollars’ worth of Super PAC advertising. Virtually none of that money came from within his district – and just a few taps or clicks can reveal who opposed Massie, and why. But does such massive spending also create the “mortal danger” and “corruption” that both Franklin and White spoke of? Will Massie’s replacement be accountable to his constituents, or to the outside forces that helped to elect him? Crucially, should we allow state-created entities such as corporations to wield so much power over state-created elections?

Efforts to contain at least a portion of political spending have begun on a new front, namely the state government level. This year Hawaii enacted a new law (Act 11), modifying the powers granted to corporations, LLCs, and similar entities – including nonprofits and unions. This law removes the corporate power of spending money to support or oppose candidates, political parties, political committees, or ballot measures – with some exceptions made for the news media. Voters in Montana recently approved a similar law, and both states would have these restrictions in place next year. Predictably, the Hawaii law has already triggered a court challenge based on First Amendment concerns and whether one State can restrict flows of money from corporations chartered elsewhere. Here in Michigan, a similar bill has been introduced by State Representative Betsy Coffia. The text of that proposed corporate spending ban can be found here: HB 6218.

Supporters of the Hawaii Act 11 assert that corporations are not people with inherent rights, but merely artificial entities chartered by State law. This gives states the authority to grant specific corporate powers – and to withhold certain privileges. Such a novel approach distinguishes the “Hawaii Solution” from past attempts to limit political spending at the Federal level. However, states still cannot restrain most individual spending or regulate spending for Federal offices. Given the aforementioned court decisions – which have allowed for Super PACs plus unlimited individual spending by various means, any reforms beyond individual State actions like Hawaii’s would require a Constitutional Amendment. Such an amendment would have to be initiated by the very Legislators who currently benefit from those billions of dollars’ worth of “Free Speech”.

In a society where money equals power and influence, can removing corporate money from elections steer us toward a more representative form of government? Should corporations and billionaires be able to influence the outcome of elections? These questions remain under debate, but in this author’s opinion we lost the Republic long ago to such influences – and the wealthiest among us clearly have greater “access” to our elected Representatives, gaining even greater wealth as government power and footprint grows. And without a true Republic, accountable to all voters, how can the power of governments over us ever become limited?

A final question only you, the reader, can answer: does a right of free speech truly exist for all Americans when “access” to politicians becomes a commodity?

Andy Evans became a member of the Libertarian Party in 2016, and has run for Cheboygan County Commissioner three times. Mr. Evans has chaired the Straits Area Libertarian Party since 2019. As a member of the LPMI, Evans has served on their Convention, Bylaws, and Judicial committees. Retiring in 2024 after 30 years working for the State of Michigan, Evans is enjoying more time with family/friends, his wife Missy – and two somewhat quirky cats.